Before taking the two mile detour to Marwick Head to pay homage to Field Marshall Earl Kitchener there's something to consider. The long hagiographic memorial plaque at the foot of the hill details all the great heroic deeds of Kitchener of Khartoum but fails to mention even once the other men who perished at this point off Orkney in 1916.

Try to understand the thinking behind why anyone would raise such a huge and grandiose memorial and not mention at its entrance anything about the other the men who died here. Twelve men survived but 642 were lost.


THE ORCADIAN newspaper in 1959:

HMS Hampshire

But Why Was Orkney help Refused?

'Forty three years ago, on June 5th 1916, at 7.45p.m G.M.T., a telegraph message was sent from Birsay Post Office to Kirkwall and Stromness. It read: "Battle cruiser seems in distress between Marwick Head and the brough of Birsay ”. Twenty minutes later a telegram with the words "vessel down" followed.

At that moment some 200 men who had escaped from the cruiser Hampshire, before she plunged to the bottom with Kitchener of Khartoum on her quarter-deck, were clinging desperately to Carley rafts and pieces of wreckage on a cold and raging sea in the wildest summer gale Orkney had experienced for years. Some died within, the first hour or two; for others it was a bitter hell, lasting until darkness fell. Twelve men survived of the ship's company.

Few people witnessed the tragedy, one or two in Marwick, and Mr Joe Angus, now a ‘grocer’ in Stromness, but then a gunner in the Orkney Territorial Forces, who saw a "cloud of smoke and flame burst up behind the bridge of the, Hampshire" and instantly gave the alarm to the man in charge of the watching post, Corporal Drever,

who in his turn raced to the post office. The. Cruiser was about a mile and a half or two miles from the shore. In fifteen minutes she had disappeared.

MUDDLE AND PANIC

Then began a long and pathetic tale of muddle and panic. The service authorities in Kirkwall and Stromness were caught unaware: they vacillated, made slow and ineffectual decisions, discouraged violently civilians who wanted to help, and failed to make urgent costal search which might have meant life to a few, who survived the waves only to be killed by the rocks. In Stromness the news of the cruiser’s loss quickly reached Mr. G. L. Thomson, honorary secretary of the R.N.L.I. branch. He rushed to Stromness Naval HQ with an offer to launch the lifeboat. His offer being declined, he pressed to see a senior officer, by whom he was told: “you have no right to interfere in Naval matters. It is none of your bloody business. And, what’s more, if you attempt to launch a lifeboat it’s mutiny. Mutiny do you hear? Any more nonsense or argument and I’ll have the whole lot of you locked up”.

In Birsay, the few who knew of the disaster, who wanted to help, were in some cases “forcibly prevented under dire threats”. One man was told by a soldier “that all civilians were to remain in their houses and not to venture near the shore or we should be fired on”. A Birsay man was certain that if people in the neighbourhood had been allowed to take a hand in the rescue operations “another fifty lives could have been saved”.

DESTROYERS AT LAST

It was not until 9.45pm that a tug and two trawlers left Stromness for Birsay. A little after 10pm four destroyers followed, then other boats. Observers in Birsay were positive that none reached the scene of the sinking before midnight. Cars from Kirkwall arrived by way of Evie; several times they lost their way and had to be re-directed. A party under Captain Mackay from Stromness made a more effective search, but were hampered by lack of information.

By a miracle, one or two men had sufficient strength to reach a farmhouse, after their ordeal by sea. The others were found on the rocks more dead than alive. The dead strewed the shore, or were picked up by ships. Not a single man was rescued from the sea itself. Someone remembers two lorry loads of bodies coming to Stromness Pier, little attempt being made to cover them from public view: Some were almost naked. They were sent down a chute into the hold of a Naval tug to be taken for burial at Lyness.

Courtesy of The Orcadian.

Back